Downsizing has long been considered the logical next step for retirees. After all, when the kids move out and the work commute becomes a thing of the past, why not sell that big, empty house and move into a smaller, easier-to-manage home? But despite what common wisdom might suggest, a surprising number of retirees are choosing to stick with their larger homes, or even buy bigger ones. Why? Because the reality of downsizing is a bit more complicated than most of us realize.
Turns out, the picture-perfect idea of shedding square footage and settling into a tidy little cottage isn’t always as appealing as it sounds. For many retirees, there’s a lot more at stake than just simplifying their living situation. The home they’ve lived in for decades is more than just a house, it’s a place filled with memories, personal touches, and maybe even rooms that still serve an important purpose, like home offices or craft spaces. Plus, in today’s real estate market, the math doesn’t always add up, that smaller house isn’t necessarily cheaper.
So, before assuming that every retiree is itching to downsize, it’s worth taking a closer look. Here are 14 reasons why more retirees are deciding to stay put, even when that five-bedroom colonial seems like overkill.
1. Emotional Ties to the Family Home
For many retirees, their home is a treasure chest of memories. Think about it- it’s the place where they raised their kids, hosted countless family holidays, and spent decades building their lives. Leaving all that behind? It’s not as easy as just packing up boxes and moving out.
A 2018 study conducted by AARP found that nearly 90% of older adults want to age in place, with many citing emotional connections to their homes as a key reason for staying.
2. Downsizing Isn’t Always Cheaper
It might seem like a smaller house equals a smaller price tag, but that’s not always true. The cost of condos, townhouses, or even single-level homes in desirable retirement communities can be surprisingly high. You might end up paying more per square foot than you would for your current home.
According to Zillow’s Housing Market Report in 2022, home prices for smaller properties have soared, especially in popular retirement destinations, meaning retirees might not find the savings they expect when downsizing.
3. Multi-Generational Households
Another trend affecting retirees’ housing decisions is the rise of multi-generational living. More retirees are choosing to share their homes with adult children or aging parents, making downsizing impractical.
In a 2021 report by Pew Research, it was found that the number of multi-generational households had risen to 64 million in the U.S., creating a need for larger homes as more people live together under one roof.
4. Home Equity as a Safety Net
For many retirees, their home represents their largest financial asset. Downsizing could mean eating into that equity, which they might prefer to hold onto as a financial safety net for future expenses, especially healthcare.
Fidelity’s 2022 Retirement Confidence Report shows that 58% of retirees view their home equity as a key financial safety net, often planning to tap into it only if necessary.
5. Taxes and Fees
Selling a home that’s significantly appreciated in value can result in capital gains taxes, and buying a new property could mean higher property taxes, especially if retirees are moving to a more desirable area.
The IRS allows homeowners to exclude up to $250,000 ($500,000 for married couples) of capital gains from the sale of a primary residence, but many retirees whose homes have greatly appreciated may exceed that limit.
6. No Suitable Downsizing Options
Retirees often look for homes that offer accessibility features like single-floor living, wider doorways, and grab bars. Unfortunately, finding a smaller home that meets these needs isn’t always easy.
A 2019 report by the Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies highlights the shortage of homes designed for older adults, making it harder for retirees to find downsized properties that suit their needs.
7. Cost of Moving
Between hiring movers, paying real estate commissions, and potentially making repairs to get their house market-ready, moving can be costly. For retirees, those costs may feel like more trouble than they’re worth.
Moving.com estimates that the average cost of a move within the same state is over $2,300, and this figure can rise significantly for retirees with large homes or many belongings.
8. Living Longer, More Active Lives
Today’s retirees are living longer and leading more active lives than previous generations. Many are working part-time, pursuing hobbies, or engaging in social activities that require space. Downsizing could limit their ability to fully enjoy these pursuits.
According to a report by the World Health Organization, global life expectancy has risen by five years since 2000, and with this increase, many retirees choose to keep larger homes that support their active lifestyles.
9. Preference for Home-Based Care
As healthcare costs rise, many retirees are choosing to receive care at home rather than moving to assisted living facilities. Having a larger home allows retirees to accommodate caregivers and medical equipment without sacrificing comfort or privacy.
According to a study by the National Institute on Aging, 80% of retirees prefer to receive long-term care at home, and having a larger home makes that option more feasible.
10. Fear of Isolation in New Communities
For many retirees, the idea of downsizing and moving to a smaller, unfamiliar community can feel isolating. Leaving behind a neighborhood where they’ve built friendships and established routines can be daunting, especially when social connections are key to well-being.
A report by The Urban Institute found that social connectedness is a major factor in the mental and emotional health of older adults. Moving to a new community could disrupt these important relationships, which is why many retirees choose to stay in their current homes.
11. Taking Advantage of Low Mortgage Rates
Many retirees who still have a mortgage are benefiting from historically low interest rates. Downsizing could mean taking on a new mortgage with a higher rate, making the financial appeal of downsizing less attractive.
A Freddie Mac report from 2022 shows that many retirees who refinanced at low rates during the last decade are less likely to downsize due to the increased costs they would face with a new mortgage.
12. Sentimental Value of Possessions
For retirees, the family home often stores a lifetime of heirlooms, keepsakes, and sentimental belongings. Downsizing means facing the difficult decision of parting with these items, and many aren’t willing to give up that connection to their family history.
A 2020 survey by The Journal of Aging Studies found that retirees place significant emotional value on the belongings they’ve accumulated over the years, which often prevents them from moving to a smaller space.
13. Renovating Instead of Downsizing
Rather than downsizing, many retirees choose to renovate their current homes to make them more comfortable for aging in place. Adding features like walk-in showers or stairlifts allows them to stay in their home without sacrificing comfort or safety.
In a 2021 survey by HomeAdvisor, 45% of retirees who considered downsizing ultimately decided to renovate their homes instead, adding age-friendly modifications to stay in place.
14. Waiting for the Right Time
Some retirees aren’t opposed to downsizing, they just don’t think now is the right time. Be it waiting for the housing market to improve or hoping to pass the home down to their children, many are holding off on downsizing for personal or financial reasons.
A 2022 Bankrate survey revealed that nearly 60% of retirees who plan to downsize are waiting for better market conditions or a more suitable time in their lives before making the move.
12 Happy Places to Retire Abroad That Cost Less than the US
Some of us dream of spending our precious years of retirement abroad without having to worry about finances. This dream might be closer than you think if you choose the right budget-friendly destination. What are your best options?
12 Happy Places to Retire Abroad That Cost Less than the US
11 of The Most Miserable States for Retirement, Avoid Them If You Can
Most of us imagine that retirement is one of the most joyful phases in life, characterized by minimal concerns and little anxiety. Right? Unfortunately, not if you pick the wrong spot to live out your golden years.
11 of The Most Miserable States for Retirement, Avoid Them If You Can
12 Purchases That Aren’t Worth Making in Retirement
Retirement marks a major lifestyle shift. The thrill of newfound freedom after working all those years is exhilarating, but it’s vital to reconsider how you spend your hard-earned savings.
After a lifetime of work, you deserve to enjoy yourself—but not at the expense of your financial security.
12 Purchases That Aren’t Worth Making in Retirement
With an honors degree in financial engineering, Omega Ukama deeply understands finance. Before pursuing journalism, he honed his skills at a private equity firm, giving him invaluable real-world experience. This combination of financial literacy and journalistic flair allows him to translate complex financial matters into clear and concise insights for his readers.
With an honors degree in financial engineering, Omega Ukama deeply understands finance. Before pursuing journalism, he honed his skills at a private equity firm, giving him invaluable real-world experience. This combination of financial literacy and journalistic flair allows him to translate complex financial matters into clear and concise insights for his readers.
